Which transmission gear oil should I use?


Without a doubt, the best transmission gear lube to use in manual transmission
cars appears to be Swepco 201. Normally, I don't make blanket recommendations
like these, but my customers simply swear by it. I've had many of them insist that
the addition of Swepco 201 can forestall a transmission rebuild for several thousand
miles. While I'm not exactly sure what magic stuff exists in the Swepco 201, I can
indeed tell you that it is the number one choice amongst our Porsche and BMW
customers. Particularly with the racing crowd, the Swepco oils have a somewhat
legendary status. For more information and customer testimonials, check out this
link in our Porsche Bulletin Boards: Click Here

Be sure that you check with your owner's manual first though - some special
transmissions require a slicker, synthetic formula than the Swepco.

Bad shifting habits that will hurt your transmission...

Hmm, there are hundreds of things you can do that will hurt your
transmission. I only really have space here to talk about a few though.

Here are two of the worst:

- Leaving the clutch pedal pressed in while at a stop light. This one is both bad fo
r your clutch and your engine. It places a load on the pressure plate spring and your
throw-out bearing. In addition, it places forces along the center of your engine's
crankshaft, which can lead to premature wear of flange bearings in the engine.
When you put your foot down on the clutch and leave it there, you are 'stretching'
the spring that is used to control the clutch, and that spring then pulls or pushes
on the crankshaft of the engine. Only doing this once and a while is fine, but repeating
this over thousands of miles will cause both your engine bearings and your clutch
to wear out prematurely.

- Slamming your transmission into 1st gear. Let's say you're at a light, day dreaming
about what you're going to have for lunch. You don't realize the light has changed,
and someone honks at you from behind. So you super-quickly push the clutch in
and slam your transmission into first gear. Crunch! This (as you might have suspected)
is very bad for the transmission - even if you don't hear it crunch. The transmission
needs time to 'spin down' as you engage first gear. Slamming it into gear right after
you let the clutch pedal out is simply bad for it. Push the pedal in for a moment,
and let the transmission 'spin down' a bit before you shift into first. Another trick
is to shift into 2nd or 3rd prior to shifting into first gear - this will help spin the
transmission down without grinding your 1st gear synchro. The same principle
applies when shifting into reverse. Wait a few seconds after pressing the pedal
down, before shifting into reverse.

Improving a poorly shifting transmission...

I won't tell you how many people have talked to me about how they had their
transmisison rebuilt (expensive), only to find out that the problems was actually
with their shift linkage bushings. Very often on older cars, the shifting ability
deteriorates as the years go by. While many people blame their transmissions
and prepare for a full rebuild, their worries may be needless. In many cases, the
shift linkage bushings have simply worn out and need to be replaced. Worn
bushings can result in sloppy shifting, misplaced shifts, and grinding when engaging
gears. Most people are amazed at the improvement that occurs when they replace
their bushings. A mere $45 spent on new bushings is a heck of a lot cheaper than
a $1500 transmission rebuild.

Shift linkage bushings are different on every car, but the results are often the same
when they are replaced - the transmission shifts a lot smoother. At a bare minimum,
replace your shift bushings prior to having any major transmission work performed -
that way you will eliminate them as a potential problem When you have all the
bushings replaced, and the shifter adjusted, the car should show a remarkable
improvement. If you are still having problems with shifting and grinding, you might
want to check your clutch adjustment, or your motor and transmission mounts, or
the fluid level in your transmission.

Myths and truths about short shift kits...

One of the most popular additions to many cars is the installation of a short shift kit.
The kit shortens the length of throw on the shifter, theoretically giving you the ability
to shift faster. Installation is relatively easy, and typically takes the better part of an
afternoon.

However, many people install short shift kits in their cars thinking that it will fix
problems that they are having with their transmission. This will not solve any problems,
and will in most cases make a poorly shifting car shift even worse. The reason for this
is that with the short shift kit, the torque arm on the shift lever is much shorter, giving
you much less 'resolution' on your shifter. It's similar to having a gas pedal that only
travels 1 inch over its range instead of 2-3 inches. You have less precision in how
much throttle you want to give the car. In a similar manner, with the short shift kit you
will have less precision on where theshift rod is placed. It's a wise idea to tackle the
core problems with your transmission (synchros, shift bushings), prior to the installation
of the short shift kit.

Ironically, many people install a short shift kit onto a poorly shifting transmission, and
then magically proclaim it 'cured.' In fact, in most cases, they didn't fix anything with
the transmission - the short shift kit is simply 'muscling' the transmisison into gear using
more force and more leverage. The bottomline? Only install a short shift kit into your
car if your transmission doesn't have any shifting problems.

Well, there you have it folks, part 2 of my tips and tricks on transmissions. Next
week, I'll finish off part 2 of my thoughts on water cooling systems, and how important
their maintenance is to the health of your car.

Thanks again for your support!

Wayne R. Dempsey
Principal Owner of DriveWerks
www.drivewerks.com

Got questions? You can email me at wayne@drivewerks.com


Porsche and the Porsche crest are registered trademarks of Dr. Ing. h.c.F. Porsche A.G.
Copyright 1997-2005, PCA Southeast Michigan Region assumes no responsibility for its contents.
For further information please feel free to contact its Webmaster.